The Magic Railroad Mini-Site

Magic Railroad - Feature Articles

mr_featurearticles_hdr.jpg

This section contains magazine/webzine feature articles about the movie - gathered in one place for fans to discover!

During the winter/spring of 2000, the following Production Notes for Thomas and the Magic Railroad were made available by Destination Films to promote the movie. Interestingly enough, actor Doug Lennox is mentioned by name in this article!
 
Thomas and the Magic Railroad: Production Notes

Brief History of Thomas

In the 1980s, a small blue train with an irrepressible smile and a sweet yet determined attitude became a beloved friend to millions of families across the world who watched him on television and home videos over and over, enchanted by his simple charms. This was Thomas the Tank Engine, a diminutive talking train, who first emerged in Britain out of an obscure series of 1940s children's books written by the Reverend Wilber Awdry. At the time, Awdry spun the warm-hearted tales of Thomas the Tank Engine to entertain his sick son.

But half a century later, young British storyteller and filmmaker Britt Allcroft intuited that the character had a far greater potential. In 1983, she took a risk, mortgaging her home and pouring all her resources, creative and financial, into forging a series of shows called "Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends" for British television. Narrated by none other than pop culture icon Ringo Starr and introducing what was to become a trademark style distinguished by whimsical visuals, fresh animation, gentle humor and a sense of constant discovery, the risk paid off. The show immediately captured young imaginations and became a favorite of parents, who were drawn in by the optical delights of the animation and the captivating, uplifting storylines. Most of all "Thomas the Tank Engine" did something special that appealed to all ages — the show melded the wonders of a child's fantastical dream world with the challenges and concerns of everyday reality, all in an utterly accessible and entertaining style.

In the ensuing years since his first television appearance. Thomas has laid tracks around the world, with television broadcasts in 123 countries and some 15 million videos sold across the globe. Thomas himself has become an enduring children's icon, beloved by the pint-sized and lauded by adults — just as Britt Allcroft believed in the beginning he could.

"I think the real appeal of Thomas the Tank Engine has always been that he leaves space for people of all ages to use their imaginations," says Britt Allcroft. "For me, Thomas has always been about bringing wonderful stories to life — and now there are millions and millions of folks around the world of all ages for whom the stories of Thomas mean so much in their lives."

She continues: "Bringing Thomas to the big screen means a grand new story for those who love him and a chance to really get to know him for those who don't. It's a continuation of Thomas' endless journey and adventure, with a whole new world of wonderful characters for him to meet."

Underlying Allcroft's script for Thomas and the Magic Railroad is her deep passion for enchanting myths and empowering messages. "At heart I am always a storyteller and great stories always inspire me," she summarizes.

Thomas and he Magic Railroad is not only the biggest adventure to date for Thomas the Tank Engine, but for Britt Allcroft as well. From the beginning, Allcroft knew she was the only person intimate enough with Thomas and his world to bring them to heartfelt life on the screen. She faced the challenging prospect of making her feature film directorial debut with a massive on-location production involving a large, international cast and cutting edge visual effects which allow the human characters to interact for the very first time with the talking trains on the Island of Sodor.

It was a challenge enlivened by Allcroft's excitement at seeing this new, epic incarnation of Thomas. "He is my baby in a sense and it's wonderful to give him a big, new life in the cinema, which is like no other kind of storytelling experience," she comments. "There's also a lot of joy as a writer to be able to direct a wonderful company of actors and technical crew to bring the characters that I've created to life all over again."

Allcroft had such a strong image of Thomas and the Magic Railroad in her head that she constantly challenged her crew to go beyond the ordinary in making it come true. Her guiding concept was for Thomas and the Magic Railroad to offer to audiences the sensation of entering into whimsical paintings come to life. For more than three months, she and director of photography Paul Ryan worked exhaustively in pre-production to create the feeling of paintings that move.

They discussed at length forging several brightly-lit locales through which Thomas and his friends travel, including: the contented railroading town of Shining Time where flowers are always in bloom; the sun-dappled Indian Valley, another town that sparkles with magic; the bustling, grey Big City from which Lily begins her journey; the endangered landscape of Muffle Mountain where an amazing secret hides; and of course the Island of Sodor, a world of joyful toy trains come to life.

"When I first met with Britt, she came to me with various artworks, photographs and film references that suggested how she wanted each part of the film to look, ideas about the mood of the film, the rich, warm color palette, everything. She had a whole visual plan in her head and she was very enthusiastic about expressing them," says Paul Ryan. "Not only was she interested in talking about specific colors and lighting designs but she had a whole emotional palette she wanted to draw from. And my job was to take her very emotional, instinctual, visual descriptions and figure out how to translate her vision through lenses and filters and angles."

Ryan found that working with Allcroft awakened his own childlike joy in playing with visuals and his willingness to go to the creative edge. "Britt is very spontaneous and she encourages a freedom that resembles a child's way of following your heart and instincts. It's a very fun way to work," sums up Ryan.

The Cast of Thomas

Into Thomas' world of talking trains and sparkling dust for the very first time travel several humans of varying sorts and sizes, each touched in some way by the magic of the Island of Sodor. Having created each of these characters, Britt Allcroft was particularly concerned that the casting reflect her highly detailed vision. "In the end, it was absolutely thrilling for me to hear so many fine actors bringing my words to life just as I had imagined them in front of my typewriter," she says.

Allcroft's choices were surprising and bold, entirely against type, giving several renowned actors a chance to show a lighter side nothing like their public personas. She cast Alec Baldwin — who is more typically the intense leading man of adult dramas — as the miniature Mr. Conductor, an 18 inch railroad man with a pragmatic attitude and a magical touch. Baldwin previously starred as the storyteller in the latest series of "Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends" episodes, so Allcroft knew he had a deep appreciation for Thomas.

"I liked the idea of working against predictability," comments Allcrofl. "To some people the idea of Alec Baldwin as this little, magical guy, this vulnerable, playful character is unusual, but I really feel that Alec has all these resources within him and more. He really brings all that to this wonderful and vital role."

Baldwin was drawn to the script because he felt the story transcended the typical genre definitions. "Sometimes you read a script and say 'this is a kid's movie' but "Thomas" is a good movie for anybody. There's a kind of Lewis Carroll quality to it all, a lot of fantastical fun. Yet it's straightforward, direct and honest in a way that I think kids demand but that adults will really like, too," he states. "There's danger and adventure for everyone, but underlying all that the characters are pure at heart."

Another incentive for Baldwin was the opportunity to work with Allcroft on her most ambitious project to date. "Normally, I might avoid a first-time feature film director," admits Baldwin, "but Britt is the person who created, conceived and mothered the whole Thomas enterprise from its inception. Who else could possibly understand this world they way she does? She's an incredibly smart and creative woman who really got us all into the joyful, imaginative spirit of the film."

Finally, there was the fun of playing the sweetly mischievous Mr. Conductor. Together, Allcroft and Baldwin forged an atmosphere of playful improvisation that carried over into the spirit of the film. "We were often in hysterics on the set," says Baldwin, "and you know that when you're having a good time that always translates to the audience."

Ultimately, Baldwin came to know and love Mr. C as deeply as he would any of the dark villains or macho heroes he has played on screen. "Mr. C is one of those characters like the Tin Man or the Cowardly Lion who is someone fun you meet along the journey, yet he has a journey of his own. He had this wonderful magical quality and now it seems to be missing," explains Baldwin. "And like all the characters, he has to figure out how to get the magic back."

The key to getting the magic back lies in part with Grandfather Burnett Stone. Playing Grandpa Burnett Stone is another unusual male lead cast against type: Peter Fonda, 60s icon and recent Academy Award nominee for his stunning portrait of the title character in "Ulee's Gold." Once a counter-cultural hero, Fonda might seem an odd choice for a country grandpa, but Allcroft responded to his ability to play an older man who has fallen out of the touch with the world. Allcroft explains: "Peter Fonda was always my dream choice for Grandpa Burnett Stone. I literally saw him playing the role in my dreams. Then when he read the script and called me to say 'I want to do this' it was absolute magic."

"I've always wanted to do a family film, because I think the very best ones have the ability to touch people just as much as any adult drama," says Fonda, "and I got that feeling from the script for Thomas and the Magic Railroad." On the set, Fonda became a mentor, taking several of the younger actors under his wing and joining in the playful atmosphere with his trademark sense of outrageousness.

Yet Fonda took the role of Grandpa Stone very seriously, comparing him to the complex Ulee that garnered him an Oscar nomination. "I saw him as a man who has shut himself out of the world of magic. But when his granddaughter Lily arrives, she saves him from giving up on life. It's about being engaged in life and believing in the possibilities. I also liked the idea of playing a grandfather, a man who has to return to his family to be whole," he says.

Fonda celebrates Britt Allcroft's insistence on putting meaning behind her adventures. "There's a lot of stuff in this story about being useful, about what friendship means, about bullies, about honesty and about the importance of family. This interested me because I think these are things that have really suffered in the last part of the century. Things have gotten messed up in society — and that's why Grandpa Stone has to come to his senses and get things back on track."

Helping Grandpa Stone get things back on track is the resourceful Lily, the 12 year-old girl who takes the wrong train and winds up in the right place to help restore magic and adventure to the world. Lily is played by the young and fiery Mara Wilson, who is quickly becoming a leading star of family films. Mara describes Lily as a "big city girl, who really likes living there with all the noise and the commotion. Only now she has to travel to the country to visit her quiet Grandpa. And if there's one thing she doesn't like it's. . . .quiet."

Mara immediately found herself really liking the character of Lily and believing in her. "I think she's someone I would probably be friends with in real life," says the young actress. "She's definitely sweet and very friendly and she ends up on a pretty amazing train ride."

Britt Allcroft was equally impressed with Wilson. "Mara brought incredible intelligence and insight beyond her years to the role of Lily. She is the audience's guide into this whole wonderful universe and she comes off as completely true and real."

One of the wonderful characters Lily meets along the way is Junior, Mr. Conductor's 18 inch, beach bum Scottish cousin, played by Michael E. Rodgers. Rodgers was enamored with the character, whom he sees as one of the film's most impishly comical. "He's just great fun," says Rodgers. "There is a part of him that is the child I wish I could have been."

Rodgers added to joyous cacophony on the set, forging a rebellious comic bond with Alec Baldwin that had people comparing them to Martin and Lewis. Says Baldwin, "When you come across someone as talented and energetic and funny as he is, it just inspires you. After awhile, he reminded me of one of my brothers. He would just look you in the eye and do exactly the opposite of what you had just agreed upon, so I started calling him a Baldwin."

Rodgers sums up what attracted many of the actors involved in Thomas and the Magic Railroad — and the source of its appeal to people of all ages: "Most of us live our lives so seriously that we don't get a chance to be mischievous and carefree So when you have a role that enables you to dance and sing and fly off trains and lie on a beach and have a milkshake, who wouldn't want to do that?"

He continues: "I think that at the heart of the Thomas stories is tremendous optimism. What kids see is a train who is a living thing who gets himself into all kinds of dilemmas but always tries as hard as he can to come out smiling on the other end. When you give to society stories that instill people with that kind of optimism, that is a wonderful, wonderful thing."

Also joining the very international cast are renowned Native American actor and activist Russell Means as Billy Twofeathers, who drives the train Rainbow Sun through the Indian Valley; young Cody McMains as Lily's enthusiastic friend Patch; and Didi Conn reprising the role of Stacy from "Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends."

The Production

Britt Allcroft knew from the inception of Thomas and the Magic Railroad that she wanted the magical terrain of the Indian Valley to be viscerally real. In an age when many fantasy worlds are carved out of pixels, Allcroft decided to go against the grain, using real locations splashed with the magic of charming performances and subtle visual effects. She describes it as "reality touched with fantasy."

"I think as a storyteller who engages in fantasy, it's fun to use the latest, 21st century technology but I think it's also important to tell stories about what is truly out there, the incredible landscape of heather lands and pasture lands and rocky cliffs," Allcroft explains.

But where in the world could the filmmakers find a location suitable to stand in for this persistently playful world?

The answer turned out to be on the Isle of Man, a small wind-swept rock in the Irish Sea that still sees horse-drawn trains waltzing down the main street promenade, which is lined with eccentric pubs, romantic dancehalls, seafront casinos and an enduring sense of once-upon-a-time. It is a place tinged with mysticism and ancient beliefs. The Isle of Man was, in fact, the original inspiration for the Reverend Awdry's railroad stories.

Allcroft notes, "To find a place that's just 30 miles long and 10 miles wide yet had literally everything I was looking for and more was remarkable. On the Isle of Man, I found places all inside one landscape that looked exactly like I imagined the Indian Valley and Muffle Mountain."

For producer Phil Fehrle, the location presented some of the production's biggest and most exciting challenges. First and foremost he wondered how he would turn this isle of thatch-roofed farmhouses and stone walls into the supposedly North American Shining Time Station.

"Ultimately, we came to the realization that Shining Time is not so much a place as a state of mind," explains Fehrle. "Rather than try to turn the Isle of Man into Maine or Ohio, we decided to making Shining Time an apocryphal, mythical place that doesn't really have a nationality. It's meant to be a place that's fun and magical, a place that doesn't really exist but you'd like to believe it could. Britt worked with our phenomenally talented production designer, Oleg M. Savytski, to come up with a design and color palette that makes it just a tad on the other side of reality."

Another challenge for everyone involved was the Isle of Man's notoriously stormy weather and rugged terrain. The cast shot in some extremely dramatic locales, including bringing Peter Fonda. Doug Lennox, Mara Wilson and others to the top of an exposed, 100 foot sea cliff that was so remote the crew had to use ATVs just to get the people and equipment there. Then there was also the freezing rain to be endured.

After the Isle of Man, the production journeyed to Strasburg, Pennsylvania, one of the great railroading towns of North America. Here the first life-size, wholly operational Thomas the Tank Engine was built by real-life locomotive engineers. The unveiling of the engine was itself a major event — drawing some 12,000 families hoping for a glimpse.

In addition to the full-size train, dozens upon dozens of models were built for the film out of the Toronto studio. In fact, the model crew shot 12 hours a day for 53 days of production. "Everything had to be planned out to the last detail so that when you see the trains moving, you never realize that they're starting out in Pennsylvania and ending up in the Isle of Man," explains Phil Fehrle.

The magical spirit of locomotion seemed to follow the production no matter where they went. Several railways ran through the sets on the Isle of Man and in Pennsylvania — and even getting to the Toronto studio required crossing a set of train-tracks.

It all enhanced the prevalent sense of play that characterized the production. "One thing that was very important to me is that we all have a lot of fun together," explains Allcroft. "There was a wonderful shared sense of humor on the set that made it a terrific experience and gave the whole thing a delightful sense of unpredictability."

The Look of Locomotion

Thomas and the Magic Railroad takes the little tank engine into entirely new territory, including his first ever interactions with human characters and his encounter with the hidden Magic Railroad that keeps the Island of Sodor going. These new experiences required an entirely new set of visual effects, in addition to Thomas's trade-mark model animation, which was kept authentically in tact for the production. But, in keeping with Britt Allcroft's vision for the film, the challenge was to create effects so seamlessly woven into the fabric of the film that they seem utterly real.

To oversee the creation of these many "effect-less" effects, Allcroft brought in visual effects supervisor Bill Neil, who previously designed thrilling sequences for the Bond film "Tomorrow Never Dies" and the sci-fi feature "The 5th Element." This time, his job was something entirely different. "On most big effect pictures, you want people to notice the effects. But here, even though we created effects for more than 300 shots in the film, I'm hoping the audience doesn't even notice, explains Neil. "When humans walk among the trains on the Island of Sodor, it should feel like believable reality. Everything is being woven in, photographic sky, steam and clouds are being stitched into digital effects, giving the whole thing the look of a slightly magic-tinged real world."

Continues Neil: "One of the exciting things about this picture is that we're using a wide variety of techniques including model animation, CGI, digital compositing and visual effects interacting with live-action photography." Neil even ended up creating a digital Thomas the Tank Engine — the little engine's premiere digital experience — for the sequences m which Thomas tumbles bravely down the Magic Railroad with Lily.

The film's primary digital effects include 1) the digital manipulation of the 18 inch Mr. Conductor; 2) digital compositing that allows live-action human photography to interact with animated and digital effects on the Island of Sodor; 3) the digital creation of Mr. Conductor's sparkling gold dust and 4) the CGI creation of the Magic Railroad itself

The original concept for the Magic Railroad was as a computer-animated representation of the renowned "Ley Lines," a theoretical network of energy tracks that link the earth's geographies. The Ley Lines theory became popular in Britain at the turn of the century and it remains a heavily researched branch of mysticism and geomancy around the world. According to the theory of the Ley Lines, places where these electromagnetic tracks begin are often magical or sacred, such as the Eight Wonders of the World, or in this case Muffle Mountain. Britt Allcroft imagined Thomas riding along his own version of the Ley Lines, a railroad of positive energy in the fabric of the universe— and she asked Bill Neil to help her develop this visually.

"Working from Britt's original concept, we created something that has a moving, living visual reality," says Neil. "The Magic Railroad, which was created entirely inside the computer, has three distinct phases: from its initial shadowy, dark lowpoint to it's full- fledged beauty as something alive and luminous."

One of the most delicate phases of production was the compositing of humans into the animated Island of Sodor. Throughout this process it was essential to Allcroft that despite the meshing of two utterly different worlds that it feel like one movie. The compositing involved intense work, demanding the precise calibration of lighting, lenses and the tiniest of physical details. It even brought up questions of Sodorian "physics." Allcroft had to address such questions as: if Mr. Conductor is 18 inches in Shining Time, then how tall is he on Sodor? The answer turned out to be that everything becomes equal on Sodor and all the humans are transformed into correct proportions with the trains — heightening the sense of magic.

"The main goal of our entire crew, whether actors, effects designers or model animators, was to maintain the illusion of Britt's worlds," comments Fehrle. "Bill Neil was able to forge images of human beings flying through the air and landing on moving, wooden trains — and make it look so great that you don't even think about the tremendous amounts of work that went into it. It just seems like magic."

The constant use of the by now infamous green screen provided the actors with challenges, as well. For young Mara Wilson, the key was to tap into her own store of magical imagery in her mind. "It's pretty funny to be pretending you're on this magical island with gold dust and railroads of light when you look around and see men with cameras and lights and electrical equipment," she admits. "But it really challenges your imagination and your ability to pretend."

Michael E. Rodgers, who plays the role of Junior, sums up how the visual effects inspire the captivating, rainbow outlook of Thomas and the Magic Railroad: "I think that this movie is about looking at the world through magic. whether it's in your imagination or through special effects on a movie screen. It's about looking at the world with optimism. With hope. With the faith that when things go wrong and people get together to solve the problems, there is a wonderful outcome. It's the basis of all the great legends of our times."

                                                          

The Green Screen Adventures of Thomas and the Magic Railroad
Putting a Fun New Movie On the Right Track

“If you don’t photograph your subject well, it’s almost impossible to make it look good in the final composite, no matter how good the computer artists are.” — Robbi Hinds csc

By Don Angus

When Thomas the Tank Engine and his roundhouse of friends came rolling into Toronto last fall to make their movie debut in Thomas and the Magic Railroad, the producers went looking for Robbi Hinds csc to help make the magic work. The transplanted South African cinematographer has the reputation for knowing a thing or two about shooting for visual effects.

THOMAS (No. 1) and PERCY at the station. Photo: David Milne

mr_featurearticles_csc01.jpg

“I think the main reason I was invited to come on board was because of my background and experience in visual effects, particularly with green screen,” Hinds told CSC News shortly after the project wrapped. “I have done a lot of study and have kept up to date on the latest technologies in terms of lighting and the various facilities that are available in order to achieve the best possible mattes for computer-based digital compositing. I take a great deal of trouble to get that right.

“About 50 per cent of the work I did on Thomas was green screen, a little bit of blue screen, and the rest of it was work with the actors on conventional interior and exterior sets at Lansdowne Studio 24 East. Eight weeks of intensive shooting.”

The Britt Allcroft production of Thomas and the Magic Railroad, written, produced and directed by Thomas rights-holder Britt Allcroft herself, is the British enterprise’s first feature film after years of near-legendary success in the triple-B world of books, broadcasting and buy-me toys. If you don’t know who Thomas the Tank Engine is, or Percy, or Edward, or Daisy, then ask any kid — they all know the classic children’s television series and spin-off videos.

The motion picture, due to be released in North America in July, stars Alec Baldwin (The Hunt for Red October) as Mr. Conductor, Peter Fonda (Ulee’s Gold) as Grandpa, and Mara Wilson (Mrs. Doubtfire) as young Lily.

Hinds, who came to Toronto from Cape Town in 1994 after working extensively in Germany and Vancouver, did all of the green-screen work for Thomas, “and there are something like 320 shots in the movie that require digital composites. The trains in the show are miniature scale of 1:30, so the main reason for most of the green-screen work is to place the actors in the scale environment of the model trains and therefore to allow the illusion in the final result that the trains are not miniatures but life size.”

Because of the U.K.-originated Thomas the Tank Engine television series, “the model trains and many of the settings existed in London.” When it was decided that the production of Thomas’s first feature movie would be based in Toronto, the trains, sets and specialized camera rigs were brought over and set up at Lansdowne Studio 24 West under the experienced supervision of British cinematographer Terry Permane.

Hinds said: “Terry, who had been the director of photography for the train scenes right from the inception of the TV series, had over the years developed some specialized techniques and equipment, such as a computerized periscope camera rig which runs on rails above the miniature sets and is able to move around very freely and get some wonderful points of view.

THE PERISCOPE lens, created by Terry Permane, allows trackside filming up to a quarter-inch from models.

mr_featurearticles_csc02.jpg

“Britt brought over her team of British technicians — the model train engineers and mechanics, the set builders and decorators. Many sets were also built by Toronto’s Gajdecki Visual Effects. Building miniature sets is a highly specialized function; for instance, the miniature trees were made specially in London out of brass and then painted, and they look absolutely real.”

“The risk with this kind of work is that the composite can look like a cutout.”

Hinds said a lot of the principal photography and scenic work for the movie, which is set largely on the mystical Island of Sodor, was shot on the Isle of Man (in the Irish Sea). Paul Ryan, “who has done some excellent scenic and panoramic work,” was recruited from Los Angeles as DOP, and he was accompanied by a camera crew, key technicians and production personnel from Toronto. “On the Isle of Man they found scenery, villages and a train station that looked wonderful.

“What remained,” he continued, “was all of the green-screen work plus the rest of the principal photography on conventional studio sets — day and night interiors and exteriors — with the principal actors.

“That’s where I came in, and what Britt and producer Phil Fehrle were clearly looking for was the ability to photograph equally well both the conventional sequences and the more technical green-screen scenes which place the actors into the background plates shot previously — for instance, the model work by Terry Permane and some of the principal scenes shot by Paul Ryan on the Isle of Man. When I photographed actors for those scenes, I matched the look by carefully studying the direction of the key light, the intensities, the lighting contrasts, the colour balances and all of those things, to aid the illusion that it was all shot at the same time.”

He explained: “The risk with this kind of work is that the composite can look like a cutout. If it’s done well, it’s seamless and the audience simply believes that the scale is real. Throughout the production that was really my major challenge, to constantly study the footage that I was to match and at the same time have the artistic freedom to work with actors of the stature of Alec Baldwin and Peter Fonda and make them look good. What very often happens when one places a light that makes an object like a car look good, it doesn’t make a person who is next to or in the car look good. So there has to be a compromise found.

“I would often look at Terry’s work, where he had placed the key light perfectly for the object, and cheat it just very slightly so that it also works for the actor. Fortunately, the schedule had been intelligently planned so that most of the model shooting was working ahead of us. They actually overlapped us by three weeks, but this was fine because it allowed Terry and me to have a lot of dialogue while I was in pre-production.”

Hinds added that he was fortunate on this production to work closely with visual effects supervisor Bill Neil of Los Angeles, a seasoned effects cinematographer and one of the pioneers in the business whose recent credits include the features Supernova (2000), Tomorrow Never Dies (1997), and The Fifth Element (1997). “We were able to have terrific rapport on how to get it right, and I think the success of the visual effects is going to be largely thanks to his input and support.

“There are technical elements and rules to shooting green screen — green is generally preferable to blue when shooting for digital compositing — and there are two types of situations. One is when there is no direct contact between the actor and the background. The green screen can then be placed far away from the actor, and, for technical reasons, as far away as possible so there’s no possibility of any of the green light — which is necessary to achieve the matte — falling on the actor.

“There are technical elements in terms of optimizing the exposure difference between the actor and the background in order to get the best possible key. I used a variety of types of green screen and different types of lighting, including a system developed in Los Angeles. The new Flo-co fluorescent tube has a wavelength that is specifically compatible with both the screen and the green layer of the emulsion on the film. This was a tool I was able to use to great advantage to achieve the best possible mattes.”

MR. CONDUCTOR is played by Alec Baldwin. Photo: David Milne

mr_featurearticles_csc03.jpg

The second type of situation “is where it is necessary for the actor to be in touch with the background, which makes it impossible to use green light. The same quality of light that’s on the actor has to illuminate the screen. Therefore, one uses a different type of green fabric or paint which will react well with tungsten light. And one has to be careful to eliminate dark shadows, which will not photograph green. The technical demands of getting a good key when an actor is right on top of the green screen are quite awesome.”

Three different types of film stock were used on Thomas, Hinds said. All the film that Paul Ryan shot on the Isle of Man was Kodak. He used a Moviecam Compact camera with Cooke and Angenieux zooms, Canon and Zeiss primes. Terry Permane’s stock of choice for shooting the miniatures with his two Mitchells and the periscope lens was Fuji F-250, and Hinds used Kodak Vision 500T and 200T for the conventional photography and “for all of the green-screen work I used the wonderful new SFX 200T film stock that Kodak engineered specifically for this purpose. We exposed close to 100,000 feet of it. And Bill (Neil) tells me they’re pulling marvelous mattes.”

“One always has to have the freedom and the ability to use one’s eye judgment.”

Hinds, who used two Arri 535Bs from William F. White, praised SFX 200T as “a reasonably fast film in which the emulsion has been engineered to produce the best possible results from green, blue and red screens. It addresses the specific wavelengths that you want for green screen work and it certainly does produce better mattes, providing that all other technical elements of one’s input are equal. You can’t get sloppy with this kind of work, ever.

“There is an adage in this business that anything can be ‘fixed in post’ these days, but it’s not quite true. If you don’t photograph your subject well, it’s almost impossible to make it look good in the final composite, no matter how good the computer artists are. It’s all time and money. It may be easy to say, ‘Let’s take a shortcut on the set,’ but it’s going to be a long-cut in post. An apparent saving in production will actually cost a large amount of money in post-production.”

For that reason, the DOP related, the production used an elaborate and expensive system of trial composites, “virtually a video studio,” to give director Britt Allcroft an on-set idea of what the composite was going to look like. “It also helped us a great deal in terms of scaling when we were dealing with train plates and getting the people to look right, often enabling us to make just little, precise adjustments in the size and position of the characters.”

On the Arri 535s, chosen partly because of their superior video-tap quality, Hinds used a set of three Zeiss variable prime lenses because he said they gave him the quality of primes with the flexibility of zooms — the ability to change the focal length infinitely from 16 to 30mm on the first lens, 29 to 60mm on the second, and 55 to 105mm on the third.

“You’re not giving up any of the quality that a normal prime would give you, but you’re getting the advantage of being able to size an actor, relative to your background plate, without moving the camera. You can simply just tweak it in. It’s a big advantage particularly when you’re 16 feet up in the air on a scaffold tower, which often we were.”

GRANDPA is played by Peter Fonda. Photo: Tom Collins

mr_featurearticles_csc04.jpg

Hinds explained that “frequently we were shooting down because, for instance, to put a person in a scene that was shot by a camera two feet away from a miniature train, you find that your camera has to be 65 feet away and maybe 20 feet up in the air. Bill Neil and his crew were meticulous in preparing detailed dope sheets on the background plates that specified all of the significant distances, lens focal lengths and settings, height off the ground relative to the subject, even where and what the key light was.

“Then, with some huge math by a specialist, all of these dope sheets were scaled up to the life-size scale that we were working to. The first thing on every setup was to set the camera according to that data. Sometimes it needed just a little bit of fine tuning, and this was the advantage of having the on-set rough composite — we could make slight adjustments in the focal length or move the camera a bit left or right or up or down.

“This is after all an artistic medium riding on technology. Very often, what is theoretically and technically right doesn’t quite look right. So one always has to have the freedom and the ability to use one’s eye judgment, to be able in the final analysis to utilize all this wonderful technology to help transfer the director’s creative vision faithfully to the screen.”

Four Toronto-based digital compositing houses are involved in the final realization of the images for Thomas and the Magic Railroad C.O.R.E. Digital Pictures, Gajdecki Visual Effects, Topix-Mad Dog, and Toybox. The “film-in film-out” scanning is being handled by Cine-Byte Imaging, and all the wet-lab processing is being done at deluxe toronto.

Hinds’s camera crew on Thomas and the Magic Railroad was Andy Chmura and Perry Hoffman, operators; Chris Alexander, first assistant; Courtney Graham, 2nd assistant; and Trevor Wiens, trainee.
                                                          
 
We'd like to thank the Publisher of American Cinematographer Magazine for permission to share this article from the August, 2000 issue of A.C.  Thanks also to ASC Magazine Store Saul, for passing our request to the appropriate people, and for following up on it.

All Aboard!

A beloved children's tale makes tracks for the big screen in Thomas and the Magic Railroad, a whimsical feature directed by Britt Allcroft and photographed by Paul Ryan, ASC.

By: Rachael K. Bosley

Unit photography by Tom Collins, Mark Jacobson, David Milne and Karen Steyr

mrbts_ac01.jpg

Left: Thomas the Tank Engine is menaced by an evil diesel in Thomas and the Magic Railroad. the animated sequences were shot in a Toronto studio using the same models popularized in the Shining Time TV Series.

Few might have predicted that bringing the warm, cozy world of Thomas the Tank Engine to the big screen in Thomas and the Magic Railroad would create a triangle of production stretching from a Toronto studio to Pennsylvania Dutch Country and across the Atlantic to the Isle of Man. But as the details of Thomas's feature-film debut began to take shape last year, it became clear that the project would require some unusual location work — including shooting in two active train stations.

Expanding upon Britt Allcroft's hit PBS series Shining Time Station (which made its American debut in 1984 and is now being rebroadcast on Nickelodeon), Thomas and the Magic Railroad follows Lily (Mara Wilson), a little girl who leaves her home in a big city to visit her lonely, widowed grandfa­ther (Peter Fonda) on Muffle Mountain . Through a mix-up at the train station, Lily ends up in the lush, idyllic town of Shining Time and is soon transported to the Island of Sodor , the toy-train world where Thomas has long negotiated with his fellow steam engines and traded barbs with bullying diesels. There she learns of a problem that her grandfa­ther, a former railroader, can help solve for Thomas and his friends.

According to cinematographer Paul Ryan, ASC, it was always a given that the Island of Sodor sequences would be shot in the same Toronto studio that had been used for Shining Time Station, and that the same models would be used with expanded sets in the film.  "If there was one known factor about the film, it was that the Island of Sodor material was going to use the same form and imagery as the TV series," says Ryan. "Britt Allcroft [creator of the series and writer/director of the feature] and the producers wanted a base of appeal for the film, and they knew kids would be the most comfortable with that [familiar setting]."

However, that certainty created one big uncertainty: how the tiny models would look on the big screen. "It was really unknown how they would translate," recalls Ryan, who was involved in about three months of preproduction. "The models are only about eight inches long, which surprised me; I thought they'd be bigger. There were ques­tions about how the trains' texture would appear, how much smoke to use, what speed to run them at and whether they'd seem out of scale, and a lot of tests were done." The film-makers also tested a variety of film stocks, searching for one that would render the models' bright colors the best. "I wanted to have a palette that would have clarity, one that would also bring out primary colors," Allcroft says. She was happiest with Fuji Super F-250 8551, and she and Ryan, a longtime Kodak user, agreed that the models would be shot on Fuji and everything else would be shot on Kodak.

mrbts_ac03.jpg
click image for larger view
The model-unit crew sets up a shot of a miniature train station for a sequence on the Island of Sodor
 
     The locations for "everything else" were where the production became really interesting. Allcroft, who had been thinking about a Thomas feature for several years, says she wanted an overall look of "magi­cal realism, like fantasy built onto reality." She elaborates, "I had a very clear idea early on that I wanted a marriage between the familiar and the mythical, to create a look [that children felt] they could step into. I wanted the look of watercolors come to life."
 
By the time she sat down with Ryan last year, Allcroft had amassed a huge pile of photographs and paint­ings whose color palettes, landscapes and use of light suggested the imagery she wanted for Thomas. These included O. Winston Link's famous steam-engine photography from the 1950s, Norman Rockwell's images of small-town America, and paintings by Edward Hopper and Don Hatfield. "From the cinematographer's standpoint, it's great to have a director come in with imagery that's so striking but not specific — it puts something in the back of your mind, and you can come back to it on your own," says Ryan, whose feature credits include Wildflowers (see AC July '99), Box of Moonlight {AC July '97) and Other Voices, Other Rooms, as well as second-unit photography on The Horse Whisperer, A River Runs Through It and Days of Heaven. 
mrbts_ac02.jpg
The period train supplied to the production by the Strasburg Railroad shares space with a modern Amtrack train in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Shooting in an active, urban train station gave the crew some nervous moments.

Allcroft and Ryan knew that a proper location for Shining Time was key. "It had to be a golden place, bright and cheery, with rolling hills," Ryan says. "We also needed it to have a real train, and we needed to be able to look down on the town from Grandpa's mountain." Because the production was based in Canada, there was "a certain push" to stay in the country for economic reasons, according to Ryan. "We considered an area in western Canada, but in the end we decided that the landscape was so spectacular it would over­whelm the story. The world of Thomas is small and cozy — Muffle Mountain should really look more like Muffle Hill." Pennsylvania, which had real American steam engines and provided locations for the last few weeks of principal photography, was ruled out as well because it was too expensive to shoot the entire produc­tion there.

mrbts_ac04.jpg

Director of photography Paul Ryan (in white hat) and his crew get ready to shoot the Strasburg Railroad in Pennsylvania Dutch Country.

     It was Allcroft, a native of England, who suggested the Isle of Man, a 30-mile-long island that lies in the Irish Sea off the northwest coast of England. While vacationing in Scotland in the summer of 1998, she read an article about the Isle of Man Film Commission's efforts to attract film production. "I went there a couple of days later and was truly amazed," she says. "Thousands of miles away from where I'd always imagined [Shining Time] to be, there it was." Ryan notes that many believe the Isle of Man actually inspired the Rev. Wilbert Awdry to create the Railway Series, the children's books that introduced Thomas and his friends in the 1940s. "There's a narrow-gauge railroad that still transports people, and it looks exactly like Thomas," Ryan says. "There's also a parish called Sodor!" It also helped that the self-governing crown possession offers substantial tax breaks and invest­ments to the film industry. In 1995, the government gave the film commission £1 million to attract such productions, and roughly 20 features — including Waking Ned Devine and Alice Through the Looking Glass — have been shot there since.

mrbts_ac05.jpg

The crew sets up on the Isle of Man, a visually spectacular location that created many challenges for the filmmakers.

 

     Thus, in July of 1999, while model unit director of photography Terry Permane and his crew began shooting the model-train sequences in a Toronto studio, the cast and crew headed to the Isle of Man for four weeks of principal photography. But while the location's landscape and financial incentives were significant assets, the filmmakers quickly discov­ered that its geography and climate created some daunting logistics.

     First, there was the weather. "There's a reason why places like that are so green," Ryan notes with a laugh. "It rained a lot, almost every other day, and Shining Time is supposed to be cheerful and sunny. We therefore shot a bit tighter than we would have ordinarily, chose our days and tried to fill the frame with color. We used a lot of HMIs and negative fill!"

     The crew also found that obtaining and transporting neces­sary equipment took a high level of coordination. "Access to things was difficult," says the cinematographer. "They don't have the kind of trans­portation we're used to, so we had to use an endless amount of small trucks [to move gear]. Also, we couldn't just call up a piece of equip­ment in a day, because it took a day to come over from the mainland and a day to get back."

     One piece of equipment Ryan had been looking forward to using was the Barbour All-Terrain Tracking vehicle, commonly called the BATT-mobile, combined with a Librahead. He says that John Toll, ASC recommended this approach after employing it on Braveheart. "I was going to use it to shoot a horse­back-riding sequence in a field, tracking closely with the horses, but we only had it for two days, and it poured rain both days," Ryan recalls ruefully.

     When the weather cleared long enough for him to shoot the sequence, Ryan says he relied on a trick from Francois Truffaut's The Man Who Loved Women. "We put the camera on sticks and did long-lens panning," he details. "Truffaut used it to follow a woman; he put the camera in the center of a circle and had her walk around the circle while he panned with a long lens. If the subject is moving fast enough, you don't notice the background because it's blurred. For my sequence, I stayed very tight on the horse and had it run in as small a circle as it could manage and just kept shooting. It's a good trick — you can get away with a lot if you're tight on stuff."

     Ryan relied on his favorite cameras, the Moviecam Compact (A-camera) and the Moviecam SL (B-camera and backup), and used Zeiss primes, an Angenieux 10:1 zoom and a Cooke 5:1 zoom. "I try to always have the SL on the set, almost like you'd have a Nikon around your neck," he notes. "I always have it set up with a short zoom or a prime in handheld mode; that way, I can use the time that might otherwise be downtime — while someone's laying dolly tracks or setting up a compli­cated shot, for example — to take the camera, run in and grab close-ups, scenics or interiors. Even on a stage, you always need that insert of someone doing something or a little dialogue scene on the side. I'm a real fan of that approach."

     The filmmakers were surprised to discover that it would be less expensive to transport a Canadian crew to the Isle of Man than to hire a British crew from the nearby mainland. "The Canadian crew turned out to be quite good," Ryan says, adding that his approach to lighting was often a bit different from theirs. "I tend to use a lot of soft light, particularly China balls, and create a big source of light, whereas they were more used to hard lights coming in with a lot of flags. We had to work fast, with many changes at the last minute, so I didn't want a jungle of flags restricting the actors and the camera. Often I'd say, 'Let's light this — and no flags!' Then I'd have to go off to talk to Britt or organize the next scene, and I'd come back and they'd say, "Well, we just put in a couple of flags over here.'

     "It always takes a little while to sort that out with a new crew," he continues. "There's a lot of creativity on all levels, and I don't want to be the sort of director of photography who says, 'Put a 2K here and a 200 there, exactly three feet away' If you do that, you don't tap into the creativity of the gaffer and grip. You want to free yourself up from some concerns."

     After processing film dailies at Deluxe London during the first week of the shoot, the production began shipping dailies to Deluxe Toronto, where the model and greenscreen sequences were being processed, in order to save money. Film dailies were eventually replaced altogether by video. "It was great to have the immediate feedback [from Deluxe London] in the first week," Ryan notes. "Shipping to and from Toronto was a long haul. Arguing for film dailies is sort of like a losing battle, but on the other hand, video is getting better." He adds he has been especially impressed with recent demonstrations of high-definition video dailies.

mrbts_ac07.jpg
Lily(Mara Wilson) takes a stroll with her friend Stacy (Didi Conn) in Shining Time

     Throughout the shoot, whose final weeks included locations in Strasburg and Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, the cinematographer and his crew found that shooting in "live" train stations required not only a visual strategy but also considerable safety measures, particularly in Harrisburg, which served as Lily's big-city home. The production used one of the Harrisburg station's eight tracks. "It's amazingly dangerous to shoot in an active station, and they actually gave us a two-hour orienta­tion about how to do it," Ryan says. "For one thing, the noise level of idling diesel engines is extraordinary all day long, and you don't always hear incoming trains. On a set, you're often running around — you want to back up suddenly or put a reflector board somewhere, for example — and it's easy to ignore the fact that a train might be coming. That slowed us down a lot."

     Shooting the Strasburg Railroad in the Pennsylvania Dutch countryside was considerably easier. "The whole operation there is very, very good," Ryan remarks. "They've been involved with a lot of movies, and [Strasburg Railroad coordinator Lynn Modinger was] very flexible." The railroad is featured in the film's shots of Lily's train heading from the city to Shining Time, and Ryan said his approach to these sequences was carefully planned to coordinate with the toy trains on Sodor. "The classic approach to photographing American steam engines is to take a low angle and make them seem enormous," he observes. "We didn't want that, because in the world of this film, trains are friendly and accessible. Instead, we took higher angles and shot more at a distance, trying to place the train in the context of a landscape [to make it seem smaller]."

mrbts_ac08.jpg

Director Britt Allcroft says she wanted Thomas to look like "watercolors come to life"

For beauty shots such as this, Ryan photographed trains from a distance in an effort to diminish their size and make them seem friendly.

 

     The train station on the Isle of Man posed a different challenge — particularly in terms of integrating footage shot there with the Pennsylvania footage. "The narrow- gauge trains there are tiny, and they would come about every half-hour," Ryan recalls. "We actually built a shell of the Shining Time Station over the existing station, which kind of freaked out the locals. We had to be very careful about how the tracks were included in our shots of the station, because they're not as far apart as tracks for 'real' trains.

     "We could shoot everything [on the island] but the angles toward the trains — those we got in Pennsylvania. In the film, you see Lily boarding the train on the Isle of Man with the station behind her, but the reverse angle of her on the train, waving back toward the station, was shot in Pennsylvania." He adds that smoke, which figures prominently in Thomas's world of steam and diesel engines, came in very handy for blending the footage. "We used a lot of offscreen smokers, because smoke helped us mask a lot."

     The interior of Shining Time Station, where Lily interacts with the magical, miniature Mr. Conductor (Alec Baldwin), was built on a stage on the Isle of Man and features an elaborate mural by production designer Oleg M. Savytski. Ryan says he particularly enjoyed lighting those sequences. "The mural is beautiful, and if you're standing in front of it, it has its own dimensionality," he observes. "But on film, with charac­ters in front of it, it becomes kind of flat. I wanted to paint it with light and accent little areas of it. I hung space lights for overall ambience, then used hard lights, mostly Lekos or IKs on full spot — it almost didn't matter where they were. So instead of being lit overall, the mural is accented with a soft shape of light here or there." Because the station is such a magical place, Ryan says he frequently lit through stained glass or used gels to create rainbow effects.

     The cinematographer worked primarily with four Kodak stocks on the picture: Vision 500T 5279, Vision 250D 5246, EXR 5245 and EXR 5248. He also used Vision 320T 5277 for the train interiors. "It was terrific for that, because I lit the interior at one stop under and it still held the outside without gelling the windows."

     Thomas and the Magic Railroad marks Ryan's first children's film, an experience he says he wouldn't mind repeating. He emphasizes, however, that Allcroft's lengthy involvement with the Thomas franchise made this project unique. "Britt had clearly been think­ing about this for a long time," he says. "I've worked with a lot of first-time directors; there's a great enthu­siasm in making your first film because you're bringing a lifetime of vision to it, really. That was certainly the case here."■

The Magic Railroad Mini-Site
 
All words/images/research by Jim Gratton and Ryan Healy unless stated otherwise